Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s recent decision to lead a Christian prayer service at the Pentagon has sparked intense debate and legal questions.
The 30-minute service, held Wednesday and led alongside Hegseth’s home pastor, Brooks Potteiger, will now be a monthly voluntary event, according to the defense chief.
However, critics, including legal experts and former Pentagon officials, have questioned whether this public endorsement of a specific religion violates the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause, which bars government endorsement of religion.
Retired Air Force Lt. Col. Rachel VanLandingham expressed concerns to CNN, calling Hegseth’s endorsement of the event as official Pentagon business a potential constitutional violation.
“It’s a violation of the Establishment Clause,” she said, highlighting worries that government officials publicly sponsoring religious services could cross legal boundaries.
A former Pentagon lawyer also called the event “incredibly problematic,” underscoring the controversy it has generated in some circles.
Despite the backlash, Hegseth firmly defended the prayer service during remarks to reporters on Thursday. He emphasized that the event was voluntary and rooted in a “longstanding tradition” of prayer within the U.S. military.
“I’ve gotten some criticism for the Christian prayer service at the Pentagon yesterday. We said it very publicly, said it very proudly,” Hegseth said, according to The Daily Caller.
“Appealing to Heaven, to God, it’s a longstanding tradition in our military. I’m very proud of starting a monthly voluntary service at the Pentagon.”
Hegseth recalled the historical role of faith in the armed forces, referencing images of George Washington praying with troops during the Revolutionary War.
“George Washington is on bended knee with the troops, praying for God’s providence and protection in that moment,” he said. “Ministers, Christians and people of faith across generations have prayed because the business that we’re in is the business of the 82nd Airborne, and we watch that 9-1-1 button for the country.”
He added, “I appeal to Jesus Christ for that protection, to speak that word and be open and willing to talk about that at the Pentagon. If they want to criticize that, they’re on the wrong side of a very important issue.”
The prayer service drew a standing-room-only crowd and featured a sermon by Potteiger focused on the sovereignty of God, referencing the book of Matthew.
Potteiger’s church, part of the Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, is known for its conservative theological principles, CNN reports.
The event highlights the prominent role Christianity continues to play within the military. According to a 2019 Congressional Research Service report, nearly 70 percent of active-duty service members identify as Christian.
Military chaplains have traditionally provided spiritual support to troops through prayer services and counseling, reflecting a longstanding practice of religious inclusion.
However, Hegseth’s active role in organizing and leading a public Christian service at the Pentagon has intensified debate about the separation of church and state.
Some critics fear that senior officials openly endorsing specific religious practices may alienate service members of other faiths or those who prefer secular settings.
Hegseth made his statements while concluding a visit to Fort Bragg in Fayetteville, North Carolina.
There, he attended a ceremony honoring the U.S. Army’s 82nd Airborne Division and announced a significant increase in hazard pay for paratroopers performing jumps, according to The Daily Caller.
This announcement reflected his broader commitment to supporting troops operating in demanding and risky roles.
As the Defense Department prepares to continue these monthly prayer events, the discussion about the appropriate balance between religious expression and constitutional limits within the military is sure to persist.
